Email The Big Red C


Ticket Booth

Get all your
online sports tickets
through Coast to Coast Tickets.
Check out our
Wrigley Field seating chart
for the best
Chicago Cubs tickets.
Buy MLB tickets
for all the best match-ups including
Boston Red Sox tickets,
New York Yanks tickets
and Houston Astros tickets.
Don’t forget to check out our
Chicago concert tickets online!

PIT/PA Watch

May 15: 3.55
Season: 3.61
NL Average: 3.73
Cubs' NL Rank: 15th

Cubs Season Record 22-15 (--)

This Series
May 14-May 16

Cubs Sweep 3-0



Final Score: 6-1

Final Score: 7-5

Final Score: 4-2


Next Series
May 18-May 20

AT

May 18: Clement (5-2, 2.78) vs
Schmidt (3-2, 3.79)


May 19: Zambrano (4-1, 1.82) vs
Rueter (1-4, 5.52)


May 20: Maddux (3-3, 4.44) vs
Hermanson (1-2, 4.67)



Last Series
May 11-May 13

Dodgers Win 2-1



Final Score: 7-3

Final Score: 4-0

Final Score: 7-3


Know Your Enemy - The Series
Part 1 - The Reds
Part 2 - The Pirates
Part 3 - The Brewers
Part 4A - The Cardinals - Position Players
Part 4B - The Cardinals - Pitching and Bench
Part 5A - The Astros - Position Players
Part 5B - The Astros - Pitching and Bench

News, Information and Discussion
Baseball Prospectus
ESPN Baseball
Minor League Baseball
NetShrine
MLB Center

Reference
Baseball-Reference
Baseball Cube
Baseball Almanac
MLB Contracts
Roster Central

Blog-O-Rama
Baseball Primer - Clutch Hits
Will Carroll Weblog
Baseball Musings
Aaron's Baseball Blog
Futility Infielder
Redbird Nation
Business of Baseball
Baseball News Blog
The Score Bard

L'Armée Blog Du Petits Ours
Cub Reporter
Ball Talk
and another thing!
Northside Lounge
Let's Play Two
Yarbage Cub Review
Clark & Addison Chronicle
Weeghman Park
Ivy Chat
Uncouth Sloth
Cubs Pundit
Tom Smith
View From the Bleachers
Dan's Cublog
Waveland Chronicles
Cub Fan Nation
Forklift
Aisle 528
Waveland Dave
Eat at Joe's
Chicago Cubs Fan Blog
Merablog
Any Team Can Have a Bad Century
Two Headed Monster
North Side Baseball
Rooftop Report
94 Years and Counting
Northside Report
Old Style Cubs
The Cubdom

Buyselltix Sponsored Links
Like Baseball? Check out
All Star Game and Chicago Cubs Prices.



Online Seats Sponsored Links
Online Seats!
Cubs Tickets
MLB Tickets


Syndicate this site (XML)
Powered by
Make RSS at BaseballBlogs.org

Listed on Blogwise


This page is 

powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Weblog Commenting by 

HaloScan.com

 Archives
08/01/2003 - 09/01/2003
09/01/2003 - 10/01/2003
10/01/2003 - 11/01/2003
11/01/2003 - 12/01/2003
12/01/2003 - 01/01/2004
01/01/2004 - 02/01/2004
02/01/2004 - 03/01/2004
03/01/2004 - 04/01/2004
04/01/2004 - 05/01/2004
05/01/2004 - 06/01/2004
Creeping Inexorably Toward A Worthwhile Sub-Heading.
Sunday, April 04, 2004

Sneaky, Sneaky!

It doesn't show up on any transaction wires that I can find, but buried in a Sun-Times piece on Aramis Ramirez is news that, in an apparent effort to acquire every jackstraw infielder on the open market, the Cubs signed Benji Gil to a minor league deal on Friday.

Gil plays fine defense at second and short, but like Damian Jackson and Jose Macias, he can't hit a lick. Yet, I'm not going to waste time on fit of grape crushing, here. Instead, this is an opportunity to compare what Jim Hendry has done in acquiring these players to what Bill Bavasi did Saturday in his trade for scrub club member, Jolbert Cabrera. Let's start by taking a look at what each man has done over their careers.

Career PA's Career Line
Macias 1395 .255/.302/.378
Jackson 2027 .246/.325/.359
Gil 1767 .237/.283/.358
Cabrera 1014 .253/.303/.353

Those career batting lines make me think about adding backup infielders to my theory on backup catchers. If there's an outlier, it's Gil, who still remains similar enough to pick up a mere 20 points of batting average and actually become Macias. The point is, they're all very comparable hitters, capable of analogous performance in the field (although, to be fair, Jackson isn't as defensively talented, and Gil doesn't play the outfield). I don't think it's a stretch to say they are players of approximately equal value. So, having marginally established that point, let's see how each player was acquired.

Acquired By
Macias Trade (Expos)
Jackson Free Agency
Gil Free Agency
Cabrera Trade (Dodgers)

Jackson and Gil were lying around, freely available, so the Cubs signed them to minor league deals as injury insurance and sent them down to Iowa. That's how things should be done. Yet, both the Hendry and Bavasi chose to trade for one of these guys, Macias for the Cubs, and Cabrera for the Mariners. Trading for this type of player is never a good idea, but we can at least see who was dealt in each case to determine who overvalued this skillset more.

Acquired For 2003 Team 2003 IP 2003 H 2003 BB 2003 SO 2003 ERA
Macias Wilton Chavez AAA Iowa 140 144 51 113 4.24
Cabrera Aaron Looper

Ryan Ketchner
AAA Tacoma

High A Inland Empire
75.1

156.2
72

133
26

33
67

159
3.11

3.45

In looking at last year's stats, I see a huge disparity in the value of what each team gave up to get their utility man. But don't believe me. Listen to an expert. In his 2004 Prospect Book, John Sickels rates Ketchner a B- and notes that "Double-A will challenge him, but...he's got a decent chance to make it." Looper rates a C, and while mentioning he's too old to be a prospect in the true sense of the word, Sickels says "he's pitched well the last couple of years, and has sufficient command to be a very useful middle reliever." What about Chavez, you ask? He doesn't make the book.

I may not find the procurement of these types of players aesthetically pleasing, but if you're going to grab this sort, Hendry's doing it the right way. Jolmian Gilcias and his ilk should be acquired as freely available talent, or in exchange for organizational filler. Nothing more valuable should change hands. Using a young pitcher with some upside or a decent middle relief candidate, let alone both, to bring in a less than mediocre utility man is an egregious misallocation of resources, made all the worse in Bavasi's case by the fact that he could have signed Jackson or Gil himself if he'd just made a phone call.

When I cry for blood after hearing the Cubs have signed a Scrappy Crappy Utility Man to a minor league deal, it's part fear that the S.C.U.M. will get significant playing time, and part annoyance that guys like Scott McClain aren't given the shot I believe they've earned. However, this is nothing compared to the way Bill Bavasi continues to be beaten and robbed on the side of the road, smiling stupidly to himself, thinking how the guys stealing his car and cash are getting a raw deal.

I may not always agree with the players Jim Hendry values, but I've yet to see him get taken. If I can't have full philosophical agreement, I'll gladly take my concurrence in actuarial form.

CTC offers Cubbies tickets
including Wrigley Field box seats,
Bears tickets
and tickets to live concerts in Chicago.

Posted by Derek @ 4:56 PM

|